Wednesday, January 27, 2010

George Lakoff on Obama and the way forward: The conservatives are winning the framing wars again

George Lakoff on Obama and the way forward

The conservatives are winning the framing wars again.

Dateline: Tuesday, January 26, 2010

by George Lakoff

In forming his administration, President Obama abandoned the movement that had begun during his campaign for deal-making and a pragmatism that hasn't worked. That movement is still possible and needed now. Here is look at what is required, and how a version of it is forming in California.

We begin with this week's triple whammy.

Which would you prefer, consumer choice or freedom? Extended coverage or freedom? Bending the cost curve or freedom?

John Boehner, House Minority Leader, speaking of health care, said recently, "This bill is the greatest threat to freedom that I have seen in the 19 years I have been here in Washington….It's going to lead to a government takeover of our health care system, with tens of thousands of new bureaucrats right down the street, making these decisions [choose your doctor, buy your own health insurance] for you."

This is exactly what Frank Luntz advised conservatives to say. They have repeated it and repeated it. Why has it worked to rally conservative populists against their interests? The most effective framing is more than mere language, more than spin or salesmanship. It has worked because conservatives really believe that the issue is freedom. It fits the conservative moral system. It fits how conservatives see the world.

The Democrats have helped the conservatives. Their pathetic attempt to make any deal to get 60 votes convinced even Massachusetts voters that government under the Democrats was corrupt and oppressive, not just inept, but immoral.

All political leaders argue that they are doing the right thing, not the wrong thing, that their policies are moral, not evil.

Conservatives understand this, liberals tend not to. Conservatives know a morality tale when they see it: Greedy Wall Street bankers, who have cost people their homes, their jobs, and their savings get billion-dollar bailouts from the government, while those honest hard-working people get nothing. Corruption. Oppression. A threat to freedom.

The conservatives are winning the framing wars again — by sticking to moral principles as conservatives see them, and communicating their view of morality effectively. In the 2008 election, Barack Obama ran a campaign based on his moral principles and communicated those principles as effectively as any candidate ever has.

But the Obama administration made a 180-degree turn, trading Obama's 2008 moral principles for the deal-making of Rahm Emanuel and Tim Geithner, assuming it would be "pragmatic" to court corporations and move to the right, in the false hope of bipartisan support. A clear unified moral vision was replaced by long laundry lists of policy options that the public could not understand, and that made ordinary folks feel they were being bamboozled. And in many cases, they were....


Add a comment

[ 2009 Features List ]

[ Send the URL for this page to a friend ]

[ Send Feedback ]

[ About Us ] [ Donations ] [ Free Bulletin ] [ Front Page ] [ Login / Manage ] [ Our Sponsors ]
[ RSS / Newswire ] [ SEARCH ] [ Subscriptions ] [ The SG Forum ] [ Useful URLs ] [ Your Feedback ]

As a paid subscriber you have access to nearly 9000 extra articles!
To buy a paid subscription: go to Online Subscriptions or phone 877-766-1223 is part of the Straight Goods family of news websites and is published by Straight Goods News Inc.
[ ] [ ] [ ]

Partner Links
[ PEJ News ] [ the Tyee ] [ DeSmogBlog ] [ Bourque Newswatch ]

© Straight Goods News, 2000-10. All Rights Reserved.
All text that appears here is protected by copyright and may not be reproduced for any purpose, including education,
without the explicit permission of the author. To inquire about permission to reproduce or republish an article, click here.

For problems, comments or suggestions, please contact
Site built and maintained by Perfect Vision (Productions) Inc.Visit Perfect Vision's Website


Wake up people! If you think you are awake, stay awake and wake up the other sleepy heads. This is going to be a rough year. Don't play at rebellion or revolution or whatever you think you are doing. Don't play! Get radical!

Unidos Venceremos! United We Will Win!

~Peta~de~Aztlan~~ Sacramento,California, Amerika



"Those who make peaceful revolution impossible, make violent revolution inevitable."

~ President John F.Kennedy ~ Assassinated November 22, 1963


No comments: